Windows compile comes in REALbasic 2 ?
I believe you are correct
Usually I don’t look for undo on those panes, do you think it will be hard to add a Dialog saying something like:
“Are you sure you want to replace all icons?
Dragging an image to the pane outside the designated area for a specific icon size will replace all sizes with this one.”
Of course, only show the warning when there is already one or more icons assigned to any/all of the sizes.
Ultimately undo should work on that window. However, a confirmation to overwriting all sizes with the dropped icns seems reasonable.
This topic is now my #1 feedback request. I sent this info in on a Xojo survey recently.
Please sign on…
<https://xojo.com/issue/56501>
[quote=446516:@Keith DeLong]This topic is now my #1 feedback request. I sent this info in on a Xojo survey recently.
Please sign on…
<https://xojo.com/issue/56501>[/quote]
Unfortunately you have too many feature requests in a single case.
It’s a single request to give Application Icons some love.
The additional details are specific issues where the current functionality is lacking and how they might improve Application Icon functionality for me. As a developer that has been doing this for decades, this my favorite kind of customer feedback.
Each of the topics are good things, but look at it from an organizational standpoint. What if they implement #2 and not the other 2? They either close the case without it being fulfilled so they can get their release note in there, or they leave it open until the others are implemented, and the change goes untracked. It’s a lose-lose situation for them, and I think odds are the case will be closed because there’s too many requests in one case.
[quote=446524:@Keith DeLong]It’s a single request to give Application Icons some love.
[/quote]
Multiple requests on one case is almost a recipe for “how to get a report never addressed”
I split it into 3
#1 is on the original case
#2 & #3 on separate ones
#1 is actually simple to deal with on macOS & the ICNS file
Less so on Windows since Windows 32 bit apps are a tad odd - 64 bit ones you could actually edit the resources after the fact
Norman, you obviously know how things work internally at Xojo…
Bonus - They are now my 1,2 & 3 ranked requests.
I know how they “worked” 
@Beatrix Willius [quote]there is an app called IconComposer that you can use to make an icns file.[/quote]
Or is it IconComposer 2x?
As far as I remember Apple IconComposer stopped working a couple of years ago.
Yeah it’s done with a command line app and a folder full of images these days.
[quote=446672:@Tim Parnell]IconComposer 2x is a handy little GUI for it too!
https://github.com/lemonmojo/IconComposer2x[/quote]
Oh, that one I wasn’t aware of.