Yes, I’ve read over the forum posts on this subject and have searched Google, but wanted some further input.
I’ve made an app for use with a 3rd party web site. Its for my own use, but I’ve considered releasing it as a commercial app for Mac and Windows. I am a Mac user and test Windows via VirtualBox using XP Pro.
I’ve shown a couple screen shots on the site’s forum and have received requests to buy it although it is not quite done - I’ve got to fix one Windows focus problem and add a preference file, plist, windows registry, etc.
Apple App Store:
I understand sandboxing and claims about quality control and gate keeper security issues; however, they want you too jump through way too many hoops like a trained animal and pay for the privilege to boot. This would almost entirely suck all the fun out making the program. I love using Apple computers, but this makes me feel ill.
I don’t really need exposure in the App store for the current product. The site it was made for has its own forum that would provide free publicity. This is really a niche product designed to save site user’s time and thus money so I see no benefit placing it among thousands of other apps.
Excel:
Way too expensive and complicated scheme with multiple products.
Monkeybread:
Too expensive and complicated. I’ve also read the interesting posts about MB users not properly using the plugin in regards to hiding things they should under the terms of MB’s user license.
Problems with Other Sites:
A. Some sites only offer payment processing without even the minimum licensing scheme for casual users. I really see no reason to use such services as I already can accept free ach payments via my bank and could simply offer the app as shareware. Unfortunately from what I read less than 1% of users will actually pay anything.
B. I’m really weary of sites that charge a monthly fee, especially ones that charge “X” amount more greater download bandwidth of the app when I can already host the app for free.
C. Many of the sites that have a pay-as-you go scheme charge an arm and a leg so they make most of the money from an app sale. Others may charge less, but their white papers on using their service seem way too complicated - certainly way more complicated than the actual app.
Preliminary Scenario:
I am considering compiling two versions.
-
A “lite” version does everything but save and open files - the actual code, buttons, and menu commands are stripped out for these functions so it can’t be unlocked to the full version. Users can still export data from the app for use on the site. Users could technically save data it generates using a external app such as a text editor, but that makes it far less convenient than the full version.
-
A full version that allows saving and opening files.
Ideally, I’d like users to be able to downloads the full version via a special link provided by the payment processor who also provides the customer with an unlock code based upon their computer. I’d be looking for something that is plug and play and does not require me to come up with my own (likely weak) encryption scheme or read a 200 page white paper on the subject.
Well, hopefully there are not too many wrong assumptions in that post :0)